“We Can’t Find the Right Workers”: Why Regional Development Planning Needs to Talk About Capability

November 20, 2026

// Economic and Business Development
“We Can’t Find the Right Workers”: Why Regional Development Planning Needs to Talk About Capability

Ask an economic developer what is holding their region back, and you will often hear the same answer: we can’t find enough workers with appropriate skills. Yet, in 2019, Brookings researchers estimated that the collective knowledge and capabilities of the U.S. workforce are worth roughly $240 trillion, about 10 times the value of all urban land in the country1. That places people as likely the most valuable asset for every region in the U.S. Many regions are not short of working age populations as much as they are short of ways to put the talent they already have to work.

The Purdue Center for Regional Development (PCRD) has been exploring this question throughout the EDA-funded Updating Industry Clusters Project. The project revisits the national benchmark cluster definitions for the first time since 2015 and aligns them with the 2022 NAICS 6-digit industry sectors. As part of that work, in 2024, we interviewed 32 national-level experts from universities, policy think tanks, consulting firms, and research institutes. Those conversations, about 30 hours in all, had several recurring themes: cluster tools are good at telling us what a region produces (an interviews synthesis is available here). However, they are much less useful for telling regions what they can do about it. As a unit of the Office of Engagement, PCRD is focused on regional development. The Center is used to evaluating and responding to issues through a capacity lens, but experiences from this project made it clear that there is also a capability element which requires more clarification.

From Capacity to Capability in the Industry and Workforce Paradigm

This is how the research and interviews define the difference between regional capacity and capability.

Table 1: Capacity and Capability Indicators
Level Capacity indicator Capability indicator
Industry Employment, location quotient Skill-relatedness to growing industries
Occupation Workers per occupation cluster Skill and credential transferability
Workforce Credentials, training completions Employment in target sector, earnings change, skills use, time to fill job vacancies

Standard cluster analysis describes a region’s capacity, asking what is present through employment concentration, location quotients, and workers per occupation cluster. Capability asks whether that base is adaptable, resilient and how it is changing over time. At the industry level, Neffke and Henning (2013) measure how closely related two industries are by tracking how workers move between them. They find that firms are much more likely to expand into industries that need similar skills as into unrelated ones, and this effect is stronger than links based on supply chains or industry classifications. At the occupation level, capability means how easily workers can move into growing occupations. Li, Nason, and Stephens (2026) argue that connections between occupations based on shared skills may help a local labor market weather economic shocks, and that this can work alongside industry policy. Henning et al. (2025) use job postings to measure how closely the skills in a local economy fit together.

All of these measures rest on skill transferability, while credential transferability is an entirely separate constraint: whether licenses, certifications, and degrees recognized in the destination occupation can block a move that skills alone would allow. Measures based on observed transitions blend the two, while skill-similarity measures capture skill distance only, so comparing them for the same region could show where credentials, not skills, are the binding constraint. The distinction matters because the remedies differ: a skill gap calls for training, while a credential gap calls for recognition, bridging, or buildable career pathways.

What Comes Next?

Over the coming blog posts, PCRD will take a look at some new ideas that came out of the Clusters research one at a time: how the capability lens changes workforce development strategy, what integrated cluster analysis looks like in practice, and why urban and rural regions do better as partners than as competitors.

In the meantime, PCRD would like to hear from practitioners. Where do you see talent in your region that is not yet being put to work?


References

Henning, M., Eriksson, R., Garefelt, P., Martin, H., & Elekes, Z. (2025). Job relatedness, local skill coherence and economic performance: A job postings approach. Regional Studies, Regional Science, 12(1), 95–122.

Li, X., Nason, D. H., & Stephens, H. M. (2026). Skill-based occupational connectivity and local labor market development (Working Paper 2026-01). Regional Research Institute, West Virginia University.

Neffke, F., & Henning, M. (2013). Skill relatedness and firm diversification. Strategic Management Journal, 34(3), 297–316.

Footnotes
  1. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/talent-is-americas-most-precious-resource-its-time-economic-development-organizations-focus-more-on-developing-it/